Network Working Group P. Riikonen Internet-Draft draft-riikonen-silc-commands-07.txt 15 January 2007 Expires: 15 July 2007 SILC Commands Status of this Draft By submitting this Internet-Draft, each author represents that any applicable patent or other IPR claims of which he or she is aware have been or will be disclosed, and any of which he or she becomes aware will be disclosed, in accordance with Section 6 of BCP 79. Internet-Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), its areas, and its working groups. Note that other groups may also distribute working documents as Internet- Drafts. Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any time. It is inappropriate to use Internet-Drafts as reference material or to cite them other than as "work in progress". The list of current Internet-Drafts can be accessed at http://www.ietf.org/1id-abstracts.html The list of Internet-Draft Shadow Directories can be accessed at http://www.ietf.org/shadow.html. Abstract This memo describes the commands used in the Secure Internet Live Conferencing (SILC) protocol, specified in the Secure Internet Live Conferencing, Protocol Specification [SILC1]. The SILC Commands are very important part of the SILC protocol. Usually the commands are used by SILC clients to manage the SILC session, but also SILC servers may use the commands. This memo specifies detailed command messages and command reply messages. Table of Contents Riikonen [Page 1] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 1 Introduction .................................................. 2 1.1 Requirements Terminology .................................. 2 2 SILC Commands ................................................. 2 2.1 SILC Commands Syntax ...................................... 4 2.2 SILC Command Argument Idioms .............................. 4 2.3 SILC Commands List ........................................ 5 2.4 SILC Command Status Payload ............................... 43 3 SILC Status Types ............................................. 44 4 Security Considerations ....................................... 51 5 References .................................................... 51 6 Author's Address .............................................. 52 Appendix A ...................................................... 52 Full Copyright Statement ........................................ 54 1. Introduction This document describes the commands used in the Secure Internet Live Conferencing (SILC) protocol, specified in the Secure Internet Live Conferencing, Protocol Specification [SILC1]. This document specifies detailed command messages and command reply messages. Commands are very important part on SILC network especially for client which uses commands to operate on the SILC network. Commands are used to set nickname, join to channel, change modes and many other things. See the [SILC1] for the requirements and the restrictions for the usage of the SILC commands. The [SILC2] defines the command packet type and the Command Payload which is actually used to deliver the commands and command reply messages. 1.1 Requirements Terminology The keywords MUST, MUST NOT, REQUIRED, SHOULD, SHOULD NOT, RECOMMENDED, MAY, and OPTIONAL, when they appear in this document, are to be interpreted as described in [RFC2119]. 2 SILC Commands 2.1 SILC Commands Syntax This section briefly describes the syntax of the command notions in this document. Every field in command is separated from each other by whitespaces (` ') indicating that each field is independent argument and each argument MUST have own Command Argument Payload. The number of maximum arguments are defined with each command Riikonen [Page 2] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 separately. The Command Argument Payload is described in [SILC2]. Every command defines specific number for each argument. Currently, they are defined in ascending order; first argument has number one (1), second has number two (2) and so on. This number is set into the Argument Type field in the Command Argument Payload. This makes it possible to send the arguments in free order as the number MUST be used to identify the type of the argument. This makes is it also possible to have multiple optional arguments in commands and in command replies. The number of argument is marked in parentheses before the actual argument. Example: Arguments: (1) (2) Every command replies with Status Payload. This payload tells the sender of the command whether the command was completed successfully or whether there was an error. If error occurred the payload includes the error type. In the next section the Status Payload is not described as it is common to all commands and has been described here. Commands MAY reply with other arguments as well. These arguments are command specific and are described in the next section. Example command: EXAMPLE_COMMAND Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) [@] (2) (3) [] The command has maximum of 3 arguments. However, only first and second arguments are mandatory. First argument is mandatory but may have optional format as well. Second argument is mandatory argument. Third argument is optional argument. The numbers in parentheses are the argument specific numbers that specify the type of the argument in Command Argument Payload. The receiver always knows that, say, argument number two (2) is argument, regardless of the ordering of the arguments in the Command Payload. Reply messages to the command: Riikonen [Page 3] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) (4) [] This command may reply with maximum of 4 arguments. However, only the first and third arguments are mandatory. The numbers in the parentheses have the same meaning as in the upper command sending specification. Every command reply with , it is mandatory argument for all command replies and for this reason it is not described in the command reply descriptions. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_NICK Every command reply also defines set of status message that it may return inside the . All status messages are defined in the section 2.3 SILC Command Status Payload The status messages defined with the command are recommendations. It is possible to return other status messages not listed with the command reply definition. 2.2 SILC Command Argument Idioms All commands that has an ID as argument (for example ) are actually ID Payloads, defined in [SILC2] that includes the type of the ID, length of the ID and the actual ID data. This way variable length ID's can be sent as arguments. All passphrases that may be sent in commands as arguments MUST be UTF-8 [RFC3629] encoded. All strings sent as arguments in command and command reply are also UTF-8 encoded, unless otherwise defined. See the [SILC1] for general UTF-8 definition in SILC protocol. All public keys and certificates that are sent as arguments are actually Public Key Payloads [SILC2]. This way it is possible to send different kind of public keys and certificate types as arguments. Riikonen [Page 4] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 2.3 SILC Commands List This section lists all SILC commands, however, it is expected that a implementation and especially client implementation has many more commands that has only local affect. These commands are official SILC commands that has both client and server sides and cannot be characterized as local commands. List of all defined commands in SILC follows. 0 SILC_COMMAND_NONE None. This is reserved command and MUST NOT be sent. 1 SILC_COMMAND_WHOIS Max Arguments: 256 Arguments: (1) [[@]] (2) [] (3) [] (4) [] (n) [...] Whois command is used to query various information about specific user. The user may be requested by their nickname and server name. The query may find multiple matching users as there are no unique nicknames in the SILC. The option may be given to narrow down the number of accepted results. If this is not defined there are no limit of accepted results. The query may also be narrowed down by defining the server name of the nickname. The is 32 bit MSB first order integer. It is also possible to search the user by Client ID. If the is provided server MUST use it as the search value instead of the . It is also possible to define multiple Client ID's to search multiple users sending only one WHOIS command. In this case the Client ID's are appended as normal arguments. The is defined in [ATTRS] and can be used to request various information about the client. See Appendix A for definition of using these attributes in SILC. If neither the or arguments are present but the attributes are, the server MUST use the attributes to do the searching. If none of the arguments, , and are present, error MUST be retuned. Server MAY use the to narrow down the search if they present at any time. Riikonen [Page 5] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 To prevent miss-use of this command wildcards in the nickname or in the server name are not permitted. It is not allowed to request all users on some server. The WHOIS requests MUST be based on explicit nickname request. The WHOIS request MUST be always sent to the router by normal server so that all users are searched. However, the server still MUST search its locally connected clients. The router MUST send this command to the server which owns the requested client, if the router is unable to provide all mandatory information about the client. That server MUST reply to the command. Server MUST NOT send whois replies to the client until it has received the reply from its router. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 11 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [@] (4) (5) (6) [] (7) [] (8) [] (9) [] (10) (11) [] This command may reply with several command reply messages to form a list of results. In this case the status payload will include STATUS_LIST_START status in the first reply and STATUS_LIST_END in the last reply to indicate the end of the list. If there are only one reply the status is set to normal STATUS_OK. If multiple Client IDs was requested then each found and unfound client MUST cause successful or error reply, respectively. The command replies include the Client ID of the nickname, nickname and server name, user name and host name and user's real name. Client should process these replies only after the last reply has been received with the STATUS_LIST_END status. If the option were defined in the query there will be only many replies from the server. The server returns the list of channels if the client has joined channels. In this case the list is list of Channel Payloads. The Mode Mask in the Channel Payload is the channel's mode. The list is encoded by adding the Channel Payloads one after the other. Private and secret channels MUST NOT be sent, Riikonen [Page 6] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 except if the sender of this command is on those channels, or the sender is server. The MUST also be sent if client is joined channels. This list includes 32 bit MSB first order values one after the other and each indicate the user's mode on a channel. The order of these values MUST be same as the channel order in the . The server also returns client's user mode, idle time, and the fingerprint of the client's public key. The is the binary hash digest of the public key. The fingerprint MUST NOT be sent if the server has not verified the proof of possession of the corresponding private key. Server can do this during the SILC Key Exchange protocol. The is SHA1 digest. The is the reply to the . See the Appendix A for more information. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_LIST_START SILC_STATUS_LIST_END SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_NICK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS 2 SILC_COMMAND_WHOWAS Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) [@] (2) [] Whowas. This command is used to query history information about specific user. The user may be requested by their nickname and server name. The query may find multiple matching users as there are no unique nicknames in the SILC. The option may be given to narrow down the number of accepted results. If this is not defined there are no limit of accepted results. The query may also be narrowed down by defining the server name of the nickname. The is 32 bit MSB first order integer. To prevent miss-use of this command wildcards in the nickname or in the server name are not permitted. The WHOWAS requests MUST be based on specific nickname request. The WHOWAS request MUST be always sent to the router by server Riikonen [Page 7] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 so that all users are searched. However, the server still must search its locally connected clients. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 5 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [@] (4) (5) [] This command may reply with several command reply messages to form a list of results. In this case the status payload will include STATUS_LIST_START status in the first reply and STATUS_LIST_END in the last reply to indicate the end of the list. If there are only one reply the status is set to normal STATUS_OK. The command replies with nickname and user name and host name. Every server MUST keep history for some period of time of its locally connected clients. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_LIST_START SILC_STATUS_LIST_END SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_NICK SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS 3 SILC_COMMAND_IDENTIFY Max Arguments: 256 Arguments: (1) [[@]] (2) [] (3) [] (4) [] (5) [] (n) [...] Identify command is used to query information about an entity by the entity's name or ID. This command can be used to query information about clients, servers and channels. The query may find multiple matching entities. The option may be given to narrow down the number of accepted results. If this is not defined there are no limit of accepted results. The is 32 bit MSB first order integer. It is also possible to search the entity by its ID. If the Riikonen [Page 8] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 is provided server must use it as the search value instead of the entity's name. One of the arguments MUST be given. It is also possible to define multiple ID Payloads to search multiple entities sending only one IDENTIFY command. In this case the ID Payloads are appended as normal arguments. The type of the entity is defined by the type of the ID Payload. To prevent miss-use of this command wildcards in the names are not permitted. It is not allowed to request for example all users on server. Implementations may not want to give interface access to this command as it is hardly a command that would be used by an end user. However, it must be implemented as it is most likely used with private message sending. The IDENTIFY command MUST be always sent to the router by server so that all users are searched. However, server MUST still search its locally connected clients. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] (4) [] This command may reply with several command reply messages to form a list of results. In this case the status payload will include STATUS_LIST_START status in the first reply and STATUS_LIST_END in the last reply to indicate the end of the list. If there are only one reply the status is set to normal STATUS_OK. If multiple Client IDs was requested then each found and unfound client must cause successful or error reply, respectively. When querying clients the must include the client's nickname in the following format: nickname[@server]. The must include the client's username and host in the following format: username@host. When querying servers the must include the server's full name. The may be omitted. When querying channels the must include the channel's name. The may be omitted. If the option were defined in the query there will be only many replies from the server. Riikonen [Page 9] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_LIST_START SILC_STATUS_LIST_END SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_NICK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS 4 SILC_COMMAND_NICK Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) Set/change nickname. This command is used to set nickname for user. See [SILC1] for definition of correctly formatted nickname. When nickname is changed new Client ID is generated. Server MUST distribute SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_NICK_CHANGE to local clients on the channels (if any) the client is joined on. Then it MUST send SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_NICK_CHANGE notify to its primary route to notify about nickname and Client ID change. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) This command replies always with that is generated by the server every time user changes their nickname. Client receiving this payload MUST start using the received Client ID as its current valid Client ID. The New ID Payload is described in [SILC2]. The is the user's new nickname. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS Riikonen [Page 10] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NICKNAME_IN_USE SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_NICKNAME SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS 5 SILC_COMMAND_LIST Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) [] The list command is used to list channels and their topics on the current server. If the parameter is used, only the status of that channel is displayed. Secret channels are not listed at all. Private channels are listed with status indicating that the channel is private. Router MAY reply with all channels it knows about. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 5 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) [] (5) [] This command may reply with several command reply messages to form a list of results. In this case the status payload will include STATUS_LIST_START status in the first reply and STATUS_LIST_END in the last reply to indicate the end of the list. If there are only one reply the status is set to normal STATUS_OK. This command replies with Channel ID, name and the topic of the channel. If the channel is private channel the SHOULD include the "*private*" string. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_LIST_START SILC_STATUS_LIST_END SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER Riikonen [Page 11] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 6 SILC_COMMAND_TOPIC Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) [] This command is used to change or view the topic of a channel. The topic for channel is returned if there is no given. If the parameter is present, the topic for that channel will be changed, if the channel modes permit this action. After setting the topic the server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_TOPIC_SET to its primary router and then to the channel which topic was changed. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] The command may reply with the topic of the channel if it is set. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV 7 SILC_COMMAND_INVITE Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) [] (4) [] This command can be used to invite other clients to join to a channel, and to manage the channel's invite list. The argument is the target client's ID that is being invited. Riikonen [Page 12] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 The is the Channel ID of the requested channel. The sender of this command MUST be on the channel. The server MUST also send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_INVITE to its primary router and then to the client indicated by the . The is an argument of size of 1 byte where 0x00 means adding a client to invite list, and 0x01 means deleting a client from invite list. The , if present, indicates the information to be added to or removed from the invite list. It may include a string for matching clients, public key of a client (Public Key Payload) or Client ID of a client. The is an Argument List Payload. The following Argument Types has been defined for invite list Argument Payloads: 0x01 - Argument is an invite string of following format: [[@]!][]@[] The may also be in format of IP/MASK to indicate a network, for example 10.2.1.0/255.255.0.0. 0x02 - Argument is the public key of a client 0x03 - Argument is the Client ID of a client If unknown type value is received or there is invalid amount of Argument Payloads present in the list, the command MUST be discarded. When argument that is to be deleted from the invite list does not exist in the list the argument is ignored. When adding to or removing from the invite list the server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_INVITE to its primary router. When the SILC_CHANNEL_MODE_INVITE is set the client which executes this command MUST have at least channel operator privileges to be able to add to or remove from the invite list. If this channel mode is not set the list manipulation is allowed for all clients. Wildcards MAY be used with this command. When this command is used to invite explicit client with the ID MUST be added to the invite list by the server. When this command is given with only argument then the command merely returns the invite list of the channel. This command MUST fail if the requested channel does not exist, the requested is already on the channel or if the channel is invite only channel and the caller of this command does not have at least channel operator privileges on the channel. Riikonen [Page 13] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] This command replies with the invite list of the channel if it exists. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_USER_ON_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_RESOURCE_LIMIT 8 SILC_COMMAND_QUIT Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) [] This command is used by client to end SILC session. The server must close the connection to a client which sends this command. if is given it will be sent to other clients on channel if the client is on channel when quitting. Reply messages to the command: This command does not reply anything. 9 SILC_COMMAND_KILL Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) [] This command can be used by SILC operators to remove a client from SILC network. It also can be used by a normal client to remove Riikonen [Page 14] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 its own client from network by providing correct authentication data. Router operator killing a client: The removing has temporary effects and client may reconnect to SILC network. The is the client to be removed from SILC. The argument may be provided to give to the removed client some information why it was removed from the network. The killer MUST have SILC operator privileges. When killing a client the router MUST first send notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_KILLED to all channels the client has joined. The packet MUST NOT be sent to the killed client on the channels. Then, the router MUST send the same notify type to its primary router. Finally, the router MUST send the same notify type destined directly to the client which was killed. The killed client MUST also be removed from the invite lists of joined channels if it is explicitly added in the invite lists. Normal client killing by authentication: When normal client executes this command the is the destination client to be removed from the network. The client MUST provide the which includes a digital signature that MUST be verified with the public key of the client indicated by . The MUST be local client to the server. If the signature verification is successful the server sends SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_SIGNOFF to network and to the destination client. The SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_KILLED MUST NOT be used in this case. If the verification fails the destination client remains in network. The hash function used in computing is selected by user or SHA1 otherwise. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) This command returns with the requested Client ID. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS Riikonen [Page 15] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_ROUTER_PRIV 10 SILC_COMMAND_INFO Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) [] (2) [] This command is used to fetch various information about a server. If argument is specified the command MUST be sent to the requested server. If the is specified the server information if fetched by the provided Server ID. One of the arguments MUST always be present. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) This command replies with the Server ID of the server and a string which tells the information about the server. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SERVER_ID 11 SILC_COMMAND_STATS Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command is used to fetch various statistical information from the server indicated by , which is the ID of server where sender is connected to. Server receiving this command MAY also send this further to its router for fetching Riikonen [Page 16] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 other cell and network wide statistics to accompany the reply. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] This command replies with the Server ID of the server and optional statistics structure which includes 32 bit MSB first ordered integer values to represent various statistical information. The structure is as follows: starttime - time when server was started uptime - uptime of the server my clients - number of locally connected clients my channels - number of locally created channels my server ops - number of local server operators my router ops - number of local router operators cell clients - number of clients in local cell cell channels - number of channels in local cell cell servers - number of servers in local cell clients - number of client in SILC network channels - number of channels in SILC network servers - number of servers in SILC network routers - number of routers in SILC network server ops - number of server operators in SILC network router ops - number of router operators in SILC network If some value is unknown it is set to zero (0) value. The "starttime" is the start time of the server, and is seconds since Epoch (POSIX.1). The "uptime" is time difference of current time and "starttime" in the server, and is seconds in value. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SERVER_ID 12 SILC_COMMAND_PING Riikonen [Page 17] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command is used by client and server to test the communication channel to its server if one suspects that the communication is not working correctly. The is the ID of the server the sender is connected to. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command replies only with Status Payload. Server returns SILC_STATUS_OK in Status Payload if pinging was successful. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SERVER_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED 13 SILC_COMMAND_OPER Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) This command is used by normal client to obtain server operator privileges on some server or router. Note that router operator has router privileges that supersedes the server operator privileges and this does not obtain those privileges. Client MUST use SILCOPER command to obtain router level privileges. The is the username set in the server configurations as operator. The is the data that the client is authenticated against. It may be passphrase prompted for user on client's screen or it may be public key authentication based on digital signatures. The public key used to verify the signature should be locally saved in the server, and server should not use public key received during the SKE to verify this signature. After changing the mode the server MUST send the notify type Riikonen [Page 18] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_UMODE_CHANGE to its primary router. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command replies only with Status Payload. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_AUTH_FAILED 14 SILC_COMMAND_JOIN Max Arguments: 7 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] (4) [] (5) [] (6) [] (7) [] Join to channel/create new channel. This command is used to join to a channel. If the channel does not exist the channel is created. If server is normal server this command MUST be sent to router which will create the channel. The channel MAY be protected with passphrase. If this is the case the passphrase MUST be sent along the join command. See the [SILC1] for definition of correctly formatted channel name, . The second argument is the Client ID of the client which is joining to the client. When client sends this command to the server the MUST be the client's own ID. Cipher to be used to secure the traffic on the channel MAY be requested by sending the name of the requested . This is used only if the channel does not exist and is created. If the channel already exists the cipher set previously for the channel will be used to secure the traffic. The computed MACs of the channel message are produced by the default HMAC or by the provided for the command. The is Authentication Payload providing the authentication for gaining founder privileges on the channel Riikonen [Page 19] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 when joining the channel. The client may provide this if it knows that it is the founder of the channel and that the SILC_CMODE_FOUNDER_AUTH mode is set on the channel. The server MUST verify whether the client is able to gain the founder privileges the same way as the client had given the SILC_COMMAND_CUMODE command to gain founder privileges. The client is still able to join the channel even if the founder privileges could not be gained. The hash function used with the is selected by user or SHA1 otherwise. If the is present and the channel mode SILC_CMODE_CHANNEL_AUTH is set the server MUST verify the with channel public key(s). If public key that can verify does not exist on the channel public key list the client MUST NOT be allowed to join the channel. Because more than one public key may be set on channel the Authentication Payload's Public Data field MUST include an indication of the public key to be used. The first 20 bytes of the Public Data field MUST be SHA-1 digest of the public key that must be used in verification. The digest is the SILC Public Key fingerprint. Rest of thePublic Data field are set as defined in [SILC1]. This way server can determine from the digest whether that public key exist on the channel and then use that key in verification. The hash function used with is selected by user or SHA1 otherwise. The server MUST check whether the user is allowed to join to the requested channel. Various modes set to the channel affect the ability of the user to join the channel. These conditions are: o The user MUST be invited to the channel if the channel is invite-only channel. o The Client ID/nickname/username/host name/public key MUST NOT match any active bans. o The correct passphrase MUST be provided if passphrase is set to the channel, and/or digital signature verification with channel public key MUST be successful if public keys has been set to the channel. o The user count limit, if set, MUST NOT be reached. If the client provided correct payload it can override these conditions, except the condition for the passphrase. The correct passphrase MUST be provided even if payload is provided. Riikonen [Page 20] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 17 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) [] (8) [] (9) [] (10) [] (11) [] (12) (13) (14) (15) [] (16) [] (17) [] This command replies with the channel name requested by the client, channel ID of the channel and topic of the channel if it exists. The is the Client ID which was joined to the channel. It also replies with the channel mode mask which tells all the modes set on the channel. If the channel is created the mode mask is zero (0) and is 0x01. If ban mask and/or invite list is set they are sent as well. The is the user limit on the channel, if one is set. The , and are the clients currently on the channel and their modes on the channel. The is formed by adding the ID Payloads one after the other. The is formed by adding 32 bit MSB first order values one after the other. The is the public key (or certificate) of the channel founder. The is Argument List Payload containing the channel public keys that has been set for the channel. Client receives the channel key in the reply message as well inside . Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_PASSWORD SILC_STATUS_ERR_CHANNEL_IS_FULL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_INVITED SILC_STATUS_ERR_BANNED_FROM_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_USER_ON_CHANNEL Riikonen [Page 21] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 15 SILC_COMMAND_MOTD Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command is used to query the Message of the Day of the server. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] This command replies with the motd message if it exists. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER 16 SILC_COMMAND_UMODE Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) [] This command is used by client to set/unset modes for itself. However, there are some modes that the client MUST NOT set itself, but they will be set by server. However, client MAY unset any mode. Modes may be masked together ORing them thus having several modes set. Client MUST keep its client mode mask locally so that the mode setting/unsetting would work without problems. Client may change only its own modes. After changing the mode server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_UMODE_CHANGE to its primary router. The following client modes are defined: 0x00000000 SILC_UMODE_NONE No specific mode for client. This is the initial setting when new client is created. The client is normal client and is present in the network. Riikonen [Page 22] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 0x00000001 SILC_UMODE_SERVER_OPERATOR Marks the user as server operator. Client MUST NOT set this mode itself. Server sets this mode to the client when client attains the server operator privileges by SILC_COMMAND_OPER command. Client MAY unset the mode itself. 0x00000002 SILC_UMODE_ROUTER_OPERATOR Marks the user as router (SILC) operator. Client MUST NOT set this mode itself. Router sets this mode to the client when client attains the router operator privileges by SILC_COMMAND_SILCOPER command. Client MAY unset the mode itself. 0x00000004 SILC_UMODE_GONE Marks that the user is not currently present in the SILC Network. Client MAY set and unset this mode. 0x00000008 SILC_UMODE_INDISPOSED Marks that the user is currently indisposed and may not be able to receive any messages, and that user may not be present in the network. Client MAY set and unset this mode. 0x00000010 SILC_UMODE_BUSY Marks that the user is currently busy and may not want to receive any messages, and that user may not be present in the network. Client MAY set and unset this mode. 0x00000020 SILC_UMODE_PAGE User is not currently present or is unable to receive messages, and prefers to be paged in some mechanism if the user needs to be reached. Client MAY set and unset this mode. Riikonen [Page 23] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 0x00000040 SILC_UMODE_HYPER Marks that the user is hyper active and is eager to receive and send messages. Client MAY set and unset this mode. 0x00000080 SILC_UMODE_ROBOT Marks that the client is actually a robot program. Client MAY set and unset this mode. 0x00000100 SILC_UMODE_ANONYMOUS Marks that the client is anonymous client. Server that specifically is designed for anonymous services can set and unset this mode. Client MUST NOT set or unset this mode itself. A client with this mode set would have the username and the hostname information scrambled by the server which set this mode. 0x00000200 SILC_UMODE_BLOCK_PRIVMSG Marks that the client wishes to block private messages sent to the client, unless the Private Message Key flag is set in the SILC packet header. If this mode is set server MUST NOT deliver private messages to the client without the Private Message Key flag being set. The Private Message Key flag set indicates that the private message is protected with a key shared between the sender and the recipient. A separate service could provide additional filtering features for accepting private messages from certain sender. However, this document does not specify such service. The client MAY set and unset this mode. 0x00000400 SILC_UMODE_DETACHED Marks that the client is detached from the SILC network. This means that the actual network connection to the client is lost but the client entry is still valid. The detached client can be resumed at a later time. This Riikonen [Page 24] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 mode MUST NOT be set by client. It can only be set when client has issued command SILC_COMMAND_DETACH. The server sets this mode. This mode cannot be unset with this command. It is unset when the client is resuming back to the network and SILC_PACKET_RESUME_CLIENT packet is received. This flag MUST NOT be used to determine whether a packet can be sent to the client or not. Only the server that had the original client connection can make the decision by knowing that the network connection is not active. In this case the default case is to discard the packet. 0x00000800 SILC_UMODE_REJECT_WATCHING Marks that the client rejects that it could be watched by someone else. If this mode is set notifications about this client is not send, even if someone is watching the same nickname this client has. Client MAY set and unset this mode. Any changes for this client MUST NOT be notified to any watcher when this mode is set. A separate service could provide additional filtering features for rejecting and accepting the watching from certain users. However, this document does not specify such service. 0x00001000 SILC_UMODE_BLOCK_INVITE Marks that the client wishes to block incoming invite notifications. Client MAY set and unset this mode. When set server does not deliver invite notifications to the client. Note that this mode may make it harder to join invite-only channels. If the was not provided this command merely returns the mode mask to the client. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) This command replies with the changed client mode mask that the client MUST to keep locally. Riikonen [Page 25] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_YOU SILC_STATUS_ERR_PERM_DENIED SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNKNOWN_MODE SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CLIENT_ID 17 SILC_COMMAND_CMODE Max Arguments: 9 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) [] (4) [] (5) [] (6) [] (7) [] (8) [] (9) [] This command is used by client to set or change channel flags on a channel. Channel has several modes that set various properties of a channel. Modes may be masked together by ORing them thus having several modes set. The is the ID of the target channel. The client changing channel mode MUST be on the same channel and posses sufficient privileges to be able to change the mode. When the mode is changed SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_CMODE_CHANGE notify type MUST be distributed to the channel. The following channel modes are defined: 0x00000000 SILC_CMODE_NONE No specific mode on channel. This is the default when channel is created. This means that channel is just plain normal channel. 0x00000001 SILC_CMODE_PRIVATE Channel is private channel. Private channels are shown in the channel list listed with SILC_COMMAND_LIST command with indication that the channel is private. Also, Riikonen [Page 26] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 client on private channel will no be detected to be on the channel as the channel is not shown in the client's currently joined channel list. Channel founder and channel operator MAY set/unset this mode. 0x00000002 SILC_CMODE_SECRET Channel is secret channel. Secret channels are not shown in the list listed with SILC_COMMAND_LIST command. Secret channels can be considered to be invisible channels. Channel founder and channel operator MAY set/unset this mode. 0x00000004 SILC_CMODE_PRIVKEY Channel uses private channel key to protect the traffic on the channel. When this mode is set the client will be responsible to set the key it wants to use to encrypt and decrypt the traffic on channel. Server generated channel keys are not used at all. This mode provides additional security as clients on channel may agree to use private channel key that even servers do not know. Naturally, this requires that every client on the channel knows the key before hand (it is considered to be pre-shared- key). The key material SHOULD be processed as stated in the [SILC3] in the section Processing the Key Material. As it is local setting it is possible to have several private channel keys on one channel. In this case several clients can talk on same channel but only those clients that share the key with the message sender will be able to hear the talking. Client SHOULD NOT display those message for the end user that it is not able to decrypt when this mode is set. Only channel founder MAY set/unset this mode. If this mode is unset the server will distribute new channel key to all clients on the channel which will be used thereafter. 0x00000008 SILC_CMODE_INVITE Channel is invite only channel. Client may join to this channel only if it is invited to the channel. Channel founder and channel operator MAY set/unset this mode. Riikonen [Page 27] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 0x00000010 SILC_CMODE_TOPIC The topic of the channel may only be set by client that is channel founder or channel operator. Normal clients on channel will not be able to set topic when this mode is set. Channel founder and channel operator MAY set/ unset this mode. 0x00000020 SILC_CMODE_ULIMIT User limit has been set to the channel. New clients may not join to the channel when the limit set is reached. Channel founder and channel operator MAY set/ unset the limit. The argument is the number of limited users. 0x00000040 SILC_CMODE_PASSPHRASE Passphrase has been set to the channel. Client may join to the channel only if it is able to provide the correct passphrase. Setting passphrases to channel is entirely safe as all commands are protected in the SILC network. Only channel founder MAY set/unset the passphrase. The argument is the set passphrase. 0x00000080 SILC_CMODE_CIPHER Sets specific cipher to be used to protect channel traffic. The argument is the requested cipher. When set or unset the server must re-generate new channel key. Only channel founder MAY set the cipher of the channel. When unset the new key is generated using default cipher for the channel. 0x00000100 SILC_CMODE_HMAC Sets specific hmac to be used to compute the MACs of the channel message. The argument is the requested hmac. Only channel founder may set the hmac of the channel. 0x00000200 SILC_CMODE_FOUNDER_AUTH Riikonen [Page 28] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Channel founder may set this mode to be able to regain channel founder rights even if the client leaves the channel. The is the Authentication Payload consisting of the public key authentication method and the digital signature for that method. The passphrase or NONE authentication methods MUST NOT be accepted. The server does not save but MUST verify it. The public key used to verify the payload is the if present, or the public key of the client sending this command. If is present also that public key MUST be saved as founder's public key. This mode may be set only if the was verified successfully. The hash function used with the is selected by user or SHA1 otherwise. The public key of the founder is sent in the SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_CMODE_CHANGE notify type so that other routers and servers in the network may save the public key. This way the founder can reclaim the founder rights back to the channel from any server in the network. The founder rights can be regained by the SILC_CUMODE_FOUNDER channel user mode, or during joining procedure with the command SILC_COMMAND_JOIN. If this mode is already set but the is different the new key will replace the old founder key and the new key is distributed in the network with the SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_CMODE_CHANGE notify. Only the original founder may set this mode multiple times and the client MUST have SILC_CUMODE_FOUNDER mode on the channel. When this channel mode is set the channel also becomes permanent. If all clients leave the channel while this mode is set the channel MUST NOT be destroyed. The founder can reclaim the founder mode back on these empty channels at any time. Implementations MAY limit the number of how many channels a user can own and how long they remain persistent. 0x00000400 SILC_CMODE_SILENCE_USERS Channel founder may set this mode to silence normal users on the channel. Users with operator privileges are not affected by this mode. Messages sent by normal users are dropped by servers when this mode is set. This mode can be used to moderate the channel. Only channel founder Riikonen [Page 29] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 may set/unset this mode. 0x00000800 SILC_CMODE_SILENCE_OPERS Channel founder may set this mode to silence operators on the channel. When used with SILC_CMODE_SILENCE_USERS mode this can be used to set the channel in state where only the founder of the channel may send messages to the channel. Messages sent by operators are dropped by servers when this mode is set. Only channel founder may set/unset this mode. 0x00001000 SILC_CMODE_CHANNEL_AUTH When this mode is set the channel has one or more public keys or certificates set, and ability to join the channel requires a client to provide digital signature that can be successfully verified with one of the channel public keys. This mode is equivalent to the SILC_MODE_PASSPHRASE except that digital signatures are used to gain access to the channel. Both modes MAY be set at the same time. Channel founder may set and unset this mode. The argument is an Argument List Payload where each argument is Public Key Payload including public key to be added or removed from the channel public key list. To add a public key to channel this mode is set and the argument type is 0x00, and the argument is the public key. To remove a public key from channel public key list the argument type is 0x01, and the argument is the public key to be removed from the list. To remove all public keys at once this mode is unset. An implementation MAY limit the number of public keys that can be set for the channel. This mode MUST NOT be set if is not present when the mode is set for the first time. Implementation MAY add and remove multiple public keys at the same time by including multiple arguments to the Argument List Payload. To make the mode system work, client MUST keep the channel mode mask locally so that the mode setting and unsetting would work without problems. The client receives the initial channel mode mask when it joins to the channel. When the mode changes on channel the server MUST distribute the changed channel mode mask to all clients on the channel by sending the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_CMODE_CHANGE. The notify type MUST also be sent Riikonen [Page 30] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 to the server's primary router. If the was not provided this command returns the mode mask, founder key, channel public key list and the current user limit to the client. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 6 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) [] (5) [] (6) [] This command replies with the changed channel mode mask that client MUST keep locally. It may also return the channel founder's public key if it is set. It may also return list of channel public keys when the list was altered. The is Argument List Payload and each argument includes one public key. The is the current user limit on the channel, if one is set. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_FOPRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNKNOWN_MODE SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_AUTH_FAILED 18 SILC_COMMAND_CUMODE Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) [] This command is used by client to change channel user modes on channel. Users on channel may have some special modes and this command is used by channel operators to set or change these modes. The is the ID of the target channel. The is OR'ed mask of modes. The is the target client. The client changing channel user modes MUST be on the same channel Riikonen [Page 31] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 as the target client and posses sufficient privileges to be able to change the mode. When the mode is changed SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_CUMODE_CHANGE notify type is distributed to the channel. The following channel modes are defined: 0x00000000 SILC_CUMODE_NONE No specific mode. This is the normal situation for client. Also, this is the mode set when removing all modes from the target client. 0x00000001 SILC_CUMODE_FOUNDER The client is channel founder of the channel. Usually this mode is set only by the server when the channel was created. However, if the SILC_CMODE_FOUNDER_AUTH channel mode has been set, the client can claim channel founder privileges by providing the that the server will use to authenticate the client. The public key that server will use to verify the MUST be the same public key that was saved when the SILC_CMODE_FOUNDER_AUTH channel mode was set. The client MAY remove this mode at any time. 0x00000002 SILC_CUMODE_OPERATOR Sets channel operator privileges on the channel for a client on the channel. Channel founder and channel operator MAY set/unset this mode. The client MAY remove this mode at any time. 0x00000004 SILC_CUMODE_BLOCK_MESSAGES Marks that the client wishes not to receive any channel messages sent for the channel. Client MAY set and unset this mode to itself. Client MUST NOT set it to anyone else. When this mode is set server MUST NOT deliver channel messages to this client. Other packets such as channel key packets are still sent to the client. A separate service could provide additional filtering features for accepting channel messages from certain sender. However, this document does not specify such Riikonen [Page 32] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 service. 0x00000008 SILC_CUMODE_BLOCK_MESSAGES_USERS Marks that the client wishes not to receive any channel messages sent from normal users. Only messages sent by channel founder or channel operator is accepted. Client MAY set and unset this mode to itself. Client MUST NOT set it to anyone else. When this mode is set server MUST NOT deliver channel messages that are sent by normal users to this client. A separate service could provide additional filtering features for accepting channel messages from certain sender. However, this document does not specify such service. 0x00000010 SILC_CUMODE_BLOCK_MESSAGES_ROBOTS Marks that the client wishes not to receive any channel messages sent from robots. Messages sent by users with the SILC_UMODE_ROBOT user mode set are not delivered. Client MAY set and unset this mode to itself. Client MUST NOT set it to anyone else. When this mode is set server MUST NOT deliver channel messages that are sent by robots to this client. 0x00000020 SILC_CUMODE_QUIET Marks that the client cannot talk on the channel. This mode can be set by channel operator or channel founder to some other user that is not operator or founder. The target client MUST NOT unset this mode. When this mode is set the server MUST drop messages sent by this client to the channel. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) This command replies with the changed channel user mode mask that client MUST keep locally. The is the specified Riikonen [Page 33] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 channel. The is the target client. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_FOPRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNKNOWN_MODE SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_AUTH_FAILED 19 SILC_COMMAND_KICK Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] This command is used by channel operators to remove a client from channel. The argument is the channel the client to be removed is on currently. Note that the "kicker" must be on the same channel. If is provided it will be sent to the removed client. After kicking the client the server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_KICKED to the channel and to its primary router. The client is removed from the channel after sending this notify. The kicked client MUST be removed from the invite list of the channel if it is explicitly added in the list. The channel key MUST also be re-generated after kicking, unless the SILC_CMODE_PRIVKEY mode is set. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) This command returns the Channel ID and Client ID that was kicked from the channel. Riikonen [Page 34] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CLIENT_ID 20 SILC_COMMAND_BAN Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) [] This command is used to manage the ban list of the channel indicated by the . A client that is banned from channel is no longer able to join the channel. The client which is executing this command MUST have at least channel operator privileges on the channel. The is an argument of size of 1 byte where 0x00 means adding a client to ban list, and 0x01 means deleting a client from ban list. The , if present, indicates the information to be added to or removed from the ban list. It may include a string for matching clients, public key of a client (Public Key Payload) or Client ID of a client. The is an Argument List Payload. The following Argument Types has been defined for ban list Argument Payloads: 0x01 - Argument is an ban string of following format: [[@]!][]@[] The may also be in format of IP/MASK to indicate a network. 0x02 - Argument is the public key of a client 0x03 - Argument is the Client ID of a client If unknown type value is received or there is invalid amount of Argument Payloads present in the list, the command MUST be Riikonen [Page 35] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 discarded. When argument that is to be deleted from the ban list does not exist in the list the argument is ignored. The server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_BAN to its primary router after adding to or removing from the ban list. The wildcards MAY be used with this command. If this command is executed without the ban arguments the command merely replies with the current ban list. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] This command replies with the of the channel and the current of the channel if it exists. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV SILC_STATUS_ERR_RESOURCE_LIMIT 21 SILC_COMMAND_DETACH Max Arguments: 0 Arguments: This command is used to detach from the network. Client can send this command to its server to indicate that it will be detached. By detaching the client remains in the network but the actual network connection to the server is closed. The client may then later resume the old session back. When this command is received the server MUST check that the client is locally connected client, and set the user mode SILC_UMODE_DETACHED flag. The SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_UMODE_CHANGE MUST be also sent to routers. The server then sends command reply to this command and closes the network connection. Riikonen [Page 36] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 The server MUST NOT remove the client from its lists, or send any signoff notifications for this client. See the [SILC1] for detailed information about detaching. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command replies only with the status indication. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED 22 SILC_COMMAND_WATCH Max Arguments: 4 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) [] (4) [] This command is used to set up a watch for nickname. When a user in the network appears with the nickname, or signoffs the network or user's mode is changed the client which set up the watch will be notified about this change. This can be used to watch for certain nicknames in the network and receive notifications when for example a friend appears in the network or leaves the network. The is a nickname that has been previously added to watch list and is now removed from it. Notifications for that nickname will not be delivered anymore. The nickname set to watch MUST NOT include any wildcards. Note also that a nickname may match several users since nicknames are not unique. Implementations MAY set limits for how many nicknames client can watch. OPTIONALLY this command may also be set to watch clients' actions in the network using their public key or certificate. The MAY be present, and it is an Argument List Payload where each argument is a Public Key Payload including public key to be added or removed from the watch list. To To add a public key to watch list the argument type is 0x00, and the argument is the public key. To remove a public key from watch list list the argument type is 0x01, and the argument is the public key to be Riikonen [Page 37] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 removed from the list. An implementation MAY limit the number of public keys that can be set on the watch list. Implementation MAY add and remove multiple public keys at the same time by including multiple arguments to the Argument List Payload. The is the Client ID of the sender of this command. When normal server receives this command from client it MUST send it to its router. Router will process the command and actually keeps the watch list. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command replies only with the status indication. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_NICKNAME SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS SILC_STATUS_ERR_RESOURCE_LIMIT SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_NICK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NICKNAME_IN_USE 23 SILC_COMMAND_SILCOPER Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) This command is used by normal client to obtain router operator privileges (also known as SILC operator) on the router. Note that router operator has privileges that supersedes the server operator privileges. The is the username set in the server configurations as operator. The is the data that the client is authenticated against. It may be passphrase prompted for user on client's screen or it may be public key or certificate authentication data (data signed with private key). The public key that router will use to verify the signature found in the payload should be verified. It is recommended that the public Riikonen [Page 38] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 key is saved locally in the router and router would not use any public keys received during the SKE. Difference between router operator and server operator is that router operator is able to handle cell level properties while server operator (even on router server) is able to handle only local properties, such as, local connections and normal server administration. The router operator is also able to use the SILC_COMMAND_KILL command. After changing the mode server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_UMODE_CHANGE to its primary router. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command replies only with Status Payload. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_AUTH_FAILED 24 SILC_COMMAND_LEAVE Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command is used by client to leave a channel the client is joined to. When leaving channel the server MUST send the notify type SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_LEAVE to its primary router and to the channel. The channel key MUST also be re-generated when leaving the channel and distribute it to all clients still currently on the channel. The key MUST NOT be re-generated if the SILC_CMODE_PRIVKEY mode is set. Reply messages to the command: Riikonen [Page 39] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) (2) The is the ID of left channel. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID 25 SILC_COMMAND_USERS Max Arguments: 2 Arguments: (1) [] (2) [] This command is used to list user names currently on the requested channel; either the argument or the . One of these arguments must be present. The server MUST resolve the joined clients and reply with a lists of users on the channel and with list of user modes on the channel. If the requested channel is a private or secret channel, this command MUST NOT send the list of users, except if the sender is on the channel, or the sender is a server. Otherwise, error is returned to the sender. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 5 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) This command replies with the Channel ID of the requested channel Client ID list of the users on the channel and list of their modes. The Client ID list has Client ID's of all users in the list. The is formed by adding Client ID's one after another. The is formed by adding client's user modes on the channel one after another (4 bytes (32 bits) each). The of length of 4 bytes (32 bits), tells the number of entries in the lists. Both lists MUST have equal number of entries. Riikonen [Page 40] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL 26 SILC_COMMAND_GETKEY Max Arguments: 1 Arguments: (1) This command is used to fetch the public key of the client or server indicated by the . The public key is fetched from the server where to the client is connected. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 3 Arguments: (1) (2) (3) [] This command replies with the client's or server's ID and with the . Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER_ID 27 SILC_COMMAND_SERVICE Max Arguments: 256 Arguments: (1) [] (2) [] (n) [...] This command is used to negotiate a service agreement with a remote server. If this command is given without arguments it Riikonen [Page 41] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 MAY return the service list, if it is publicly available. The is a service specific identifier, and the MAY be used to authenticate the requester to the remote service. The authentication to a service may be based on previous agreement with the requester and the service provider. The command MAY also take additional service specific arguments. This document does not specify any services. How the services are configured and put available in a server is also out of scope of this document. This command MAY be used by client to start using some service in a server, but it also MAY be used by server to negotiate to start using a service in some other server or router. After the negotiation is done both of the parties need to know from the service identifier how the service can be used. The service can be considered to be a protocol which both of the parties need to support. Reply messages to the command: Max Arguments: 256 Arguments: (1) (2) [] (3) [] (n) [...] This command MAY reply with the when command is given without arguments, and the list is a comma separated list of service identifiers. The is the service that the sender requested and this is provided when the server has accepted the sender to use the . The command reply MAY also have additional service specific arguments. Status messages: SILC_STATUS_OK SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVICE SILC_STATUS_ERR_AUTH_FAILED SILC_STATUS_ERR_PERM_DENIED 28 - 199 Riikonen [Page 42] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Currently undefined commands. 200 - 254 These commands are reserved for private use and will not be defined in this document. 255 SILC_COMMAND_MAX Reserved command. This must not be sent. 2.4 SILC Command Status Payload Command Status Payload is sent in command reply messages to indicate the status of the command. The payload is one of argument in the command thus this is the data area in Command Argument Payload described in [SILC2]. The payload is only 2 bytes in length. The following diagram represents the Command Status Payload (fields are always in MSB first order). 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+ | Status | Error | +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+ Figure 6: SILC Command Status Payload o Status (1 byte) - Indicates the status message type, error, start of list, entry of list or end of list. o Error (1 byte) - Indicates the error if the Status field is some list status, which means there are list of errors. The values in Status and Error fields are set according the following rules: o If there is single reply and error has not occurred then Status field includes value SILC_STATUS_OK, and the Error field MUST be ignored (and set to zero value). Riikonen [Page 43] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 o If there is single error, then Status field includes one of the error values, and the Error field MUST be ignored (and set to zero value). o If there will be multiple successful command replies then Status field includes SILC_STATUS_LIST_START, SILC_STATUS_LIST_ITEM or SILC_STATUS_LIST_END value, and Error field is set to SILC_STATUS_OK. o If there are multiple error replies then Status field includes SILC_STATUS_LIST_START, SILC_STATUS_LIST_ITEM or SILC_STATUS_LIST_END value, and the Error field includes the error value. This way it is possible to send single successful or single error reply, but also multiple successful and multiple error replies. Note that it is possible to send both list of successful replies and list of error replies at the same time, however in this case the list of error replies MUST be sent after the successful replies. This way the recipient may ignore the multiple errors if it wishes to do so. Also note that in this case the successful and error replies belong to the same list. All Status messages are described in the next section. 3 SILC Status Types Status messages are returned in SILC protocol in command reply packet and in notify packet. The SILC_PACKET_COMMAND_REPLY is the command reply packet and status types are sent inside the Status Payload as one of command reply argument, as defined in previous sections. For SILC_PACKET_NOTIFY packet they can be sent as defined in [SILC2] for SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_ERROR type. The same types defined in this section are used in both cases. When returning status messages in the command reply message they indicate whether the command was executed without errors. If error occurred the status indicates which error occurred. If error occurred the arguments to the command replies are dictated by the error type. If arguments are to be sent, they are defined below with the error status types. When sending status messages in SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_ERROR notify type they always send some error status. Usually they are sent to indicate that error occurred while processing some SILC packet. Riikonen [Page 44] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 Please see the [SILC1] and [SILC2] for more information sending status types in SILC_NOTIFY_TYPE_ERROR notify. The Status Types are only numeric values and the receiver must convert the numeric values into human readable messages if this is desired in the application. List of all defined status types: Generic status messages: 0 SILC_STATUS_OK Ok status. Everything went Ok. The status payload maybe safely ignored in this case. 1 SILC_STATUS_LIST_START Start of the list. There will be several command replies and this reply is the start of the list. 2 SILC_STATUS_LIST_ITEM Item in the list. This is one of the item in the list but not the first or last one. 3 SILC_STATUS_LIST_END End of the list. There were several command replies and this reply is the last of the list. There won't be other replies belonging to this list after this one. 4 - 9 Currently undefined and has been reserved for the future. Error status message: 10 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_NICK "No such nickname". Requested nickname does not exist. The next argument MUST be the requested nickname. 11 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL Riikonen [Page 45] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 "No such channel". Requested channel name does not exist. The next argument MUST be the requested channel name. 12 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER "No such server". Requested server name does not exist. The next argument MUST be the requested server name. 13 SILC_STATUS_ERR_INCOMPLETE_INFORMATION "Incomplete registration information". Information remote sent was incomplete. 14 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_RECIPIENT "No recipient given". Command required recipient which was not provided. 15 SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNKNOWN_COMMAND "Unknown command". Command sent to server is unknown by the server. 16 SILC_STATUS_ERR_WILDCARDS "Wildcards cannot be used". Wildcards were provided but they weren't permitted. 17 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CLIENT_ID "No Client ID given". Client ID were expected as command parameter but were not found. 18 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_ID "No Channel ID given". Channel ID were expected as command parameter but were not found. 19 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SERVER_ID "No Serve ID given". Server ID were expected as command parameter but were not found. 20 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CLIENT_ID "Bad Client ID". Client ID provided were erroneous. The next argument MUST be the provided ID. Riikonen [Page 46] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 21 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL_ID "Bad Channel ID". Channel ID provided were erroneous. The next argument MUST be the provided ID. 22 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CLIENT_ID "No such Client ID". Client ID provided does not exist. The unknown Client ID MUST be provided as next argument in the reply. 23 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_CHANNEL_ID "No such Channel ID". Channel ID provided does not exist. The unknown Channel ID MUST be provided as next argument in the reply. 24 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NICKNAME_IN_USE "Nickname already exists". Nickname created could not be registered because number of same nicknames were already set to maximum. This is not expected to happen in real life but is possible to occur. 25 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ON_CHANNEL "You are not on that channel". The command were specified for channel user is not currently on. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 26 SILC_STATUS_ERR_USER_NOT_ON_CHANNEL "They are not on channel". The requested target client is not on requested channel. The next two arguments, in this order, MUST be the requested Client ID and Channel ID. 27 SILC_STATUS_ERR_USER_ON_CHANNEL "User already on channel". User were invited on channel they already are on. The next two arguments, in this order, MUST be the requested Client ID and Channel ID. 28 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_REGISTERED "You have not registered". User executed command that requires the client to be registered on the server before it may be executed. Riikonen [Page 47] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 29 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_ENOUGH_PARAMS "Not enough parameters". Command requires more parameters than provided. 30 SILC_STATUS_ERR_TOO_MANY_PARAMS "Too many parameters". Too many parameters were provided for the command. 31 SILC_STATUS_ERR_PERM_DENIED "Permission denied". Generic permission denied error status to indicate disallowed access. 32 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BANNED_FROM_SERVER "You are banned from this server". The client tried to register on server that has explicitly denied this host to connect. 33 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_PASSWORD "Cannot join channel. Incorrect password". Password provided for channel were not accepted. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 34 SILC_STATUS_ERR_CHANNEL_IS_FULL "Cannot join channel. Channel is full". The channel is full and client cannot be joined to it. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 35 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_INVITED "Cannot join channel. You have not been invited". The channel is invite only channel and client has not been invited. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 36 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BANNED_FROM_CHANNEL "Cannot join channel. You have been banned". The client has been banned from the channel. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 37 SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNKNOWN_MODE "Unknown mode". Mode provided by the client were unknown to the server. Riikonen [Page 48] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 38 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_YOU "Cannot change mode for other users". User tried to change someone else's mode. 39 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_PRIV "Permission denied. You are not channel operator". Command may be executed only by channel operator. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 40 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_CHANNEL_FOPRIV "Permission denied. You are not channel founder". Command may be executed only by channel operator. The next argument MUST be the Channel ID. 41 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SERVER_PRIV "Permission denied. You are not server operator". Command may be executed only by server operator. 42 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_ROUTER_PRIV "Permission denied. You are not SILC operator". Command may be executed only by router (SILC) operator. 43 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_NICKNAME "Bad nickname". Nickname requested contained illegal characters or were malformed. 44 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_CHANNEL "Bad channel name". Channel requested contained illegal characters or were malformed. 45 SILC_STATUS_ERR_AUTH_FAILED "Authentication failed". The authentication data sent as argument were wrong and thus authentication failed. 46 SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNKOWN_ALGORITHM "The algorithm was not supported." The server does not support the requested algorithm. The next argument MUST be the algorithm name string. Riikonen [Page 49] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 47 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVER_ID "No such Server ID". Server ID provided does not exist. The unknown Server ID MUST be provided as next argument in the reply. 48 SILC_STATUS_ERR_RESOURCE_LIMIT "No more resources available". This can mean that server cannot or will not accept something due to resource limitations. 49 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NO_SUCH_SERVICE "Service does not exist". Requested service identifier is unknown. The next argument MUST be the service identifier. 50 SILC_STATUS_ERR_NOT_AUTHENTICATED "You have not been authenticated". Remote connection is not authenticated even though it is supposed to be. 51 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_SERVER_ID "Server ID is not valid". Provided server ID is not valid. The next argument MUST be the provided ID. 52 SILC_STATUS_ERR_KEY_EXCHANGE_FAILED "Key exchange failed". Key Exchange protocol failed. 53 SILC_STATUS_ERR_BAD_VERSION "Bad version". Protocol or software version mismatch. 54 SILC_STATUS_ERR_TIMEDOUT "Operation timed out". Operation or service request timed out, and thus was not processed. 55 SILC_STATUS_ERR_UNSUPPORTED_PUBLIC_KEY "Unsupported public key type". The public key or certificate type is not supported in this implementation. 56 SILC_STATUS_ERR_OPERATION_ALLOWED "Operation is not allowed". A operation, for example a command, is not allowed or it's execution is not allowed. Riikonen [Page 50] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 4 Security Considerations Security is central to the design of this protocol, and these security considerations permeate the specification. Common security considerations such as keeping private keys truly private and using adequate lengths for symmetric and asymmetric keys must be followed in order to maintain the security of this protocol. 5 References [SILC1] Riikonen, P., "Secure Internet Live Conferencing (SILC), Protocol Specification", Internet Draft, January 2007. [SILC2] Riikonen, P., "SILC Packet Protocol", Internet Draft, January 2007. [SILC3] Riikonen, P., "SILC Key Exchange and Authentication Protocols", Internet Draft, January 2007. [IRC] Oikarinen, J., and Reed D., "Internet Relay Chat Protocol", RFC 1459, May 1993. [IRC-ARCH] Kalt, C., "Internet Relay Chat: Architecture", RFC 2810, April 2000. [IRC-CHAN] Kalt, C., "Internet Relay Chat: Channel Management", RFC 2811, April 2000. [IRC-CLIENT] Kalt, C., "Internet Relay Chat: Client Protocol", RFC 2812, April 2000. [IRC-SERVER] Kalt, C., "Internet Relay Chat: Server Protocol", RFC 2813, April 2000. [SSH-TRANS] Ylonen, T., et al, "SSH Transport Layer Protocol", Internet Draft. [PGP] Callas, J., et al, "OpenPGP Message Format", RFC 2440, November 1998. [SPKI] Ellison C., et al, "SPKI Certificate Theory", RFC 2693, September 1999. [PKIX-Part1] Housley, R., et al, "Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure, Certificate and CRL Profile", RFC 2459, January 1999. Riikonen [Page 51] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 [Schneier] Schneier, B., "Applied Cryptography Second Edition", John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, 1996. [Menezes] Menezes, A., et al, "Handbook of Applied Cryptography", CRC Press 1997. [OAKLEY] Orman, H., "The OAKLEY Key Determination Protocol", RFC 2412, November 1998. [ISAKMP] Maughan D., et al, "Internet Security Association and Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)", RFC 2408, November 1998. [IKE] Harkins D., and Carrel D., "The Internet Key Exchange (IKE)", RFC 2409, November 1998. [HMAC] Krawczyk, H., "HMAC: Keyed-Hashing for Message Authentication", RFC 2104, February 1997. [PKCS1] Kalinski, B., and Staddon, J., "PKCS #1 RSA Cryptography Specifications, Version 2.0", RFC 2437, October 1998. [RFC2119] Bradner, S., "Key Words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement Levels", BCP 14, RFC 2119, March 1997. [RFC3629] Yergeau, F., "UTF-8, a transformation format of ISO 10646", RFC 3629, November 2003. [ATTRS] Riikonen, P., "User Online Presence and Information Attributes", Internet Draft, May 2002. 6 Author's Address Pekka Riikonen Helsinki Finland EMail: priikone@iki.fi Appendix A This appendix defines the usage of the argument in the SILC_COMMAND_WHOIS command. The attributes are defined in [ATTRS], and may be used to request additional information about the user. Since the information that may be requested using the attributes is something that server cannot deliver to the sender, it is possible to send the WHOIS Riikonen [Page 52] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 command directly to the destination client whom will then provide the requested attributes. This requires the servers to relay the WHOIS command to the client, and it requires capability for handling the WHOIS command in the client end. The MAY include several attributes that are requested. The format and encoding of the is as defined in [ATTRS]. When argument is set the server MAY process the attributes to see whether it can narrow down the WHOIS search, for example when searching with a nickname. The normal servers MUST process the WHOIS command as normal WHOIS command, that is to send the command directly to the router. The router MAY process the attributes, but it MUST send the command to the server that owns the requested client. The server that owns the client and receives the command MUST check whether the client is detached from the network. If it is detached, that is the user mode has the SILC_UMODE_DETACHED mode set, it SHOULD process the attributes and provide as many of the requested attributes as possible and then send reply back to the sender. If the client is active in the network it MUST send the command to the client for processing. The client receiving WHOIS command SHOULD check whether the argument is set. If it is not set then the WHOIS command SHOULD be discarded. The client processes the requested attributes and SHOULD reply to each of the requested attribute with either valid value, or with an indication that the requested attribute is not known or supported. This is to be done as defined in [ATTRS]. The client always MUST send a reply to the command when some attributes were requested. The client MAY also add additional attributes to the reply even if they were not requested. The client MAY also digitally sign the attributes with ATTRIBUTE_USER_DIGITAL_SIGNATURE as defined in [ATTRS]. Then the client sends the reply back to the sender of the command. The command reply that client assembles does not need to include any other argument but the (1), and the (11). The server receiving reply from client MUST allow this sort of command reply for WHOIS command. The information received from the client MAY be cached in the server's end. The caching may be desired for example if the client can be detached from the network. This way the server is then able to provide at least partial information for a requester. The server MAY also process the command reply and verify whether the attributes provided in the reply are actually valid. If it can do this, and verify that they indeed are valid values it MAY append a digital signature at the end of the attributes with the ATTRIBUTE_SERVER_DIGITAL_SIGNATURE as defined in [ATTRS]. The Riikonen [Page 53] Internet Draft 15 January 2007 server then MUST provide valid WHOIS command reply to the sender of the command. Other servers and routers that receive the command reply en route to the original sender MAY also cache the information. The client which receives the command reply to the WHOIS command SHOULD verify the ATTRIBUTE_USER_DIGITAL_SIGNATURE and the ATTRIBUTE_SERVER_DIGITAL_SIGNATURE if they are provided. Full Copyright Statement Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2007). This document is subject to the rights, licenses and restrictions contained in BCP 78, and except as set forth therein, the authors retain all their rights. This document and the information contained herein are provided on an "AS IS" basis and THE CONTRIBUTOR, THE ORGANIZATION HE/SHE REPRESENTS OR IS SPONSORED BY (IF ANY), THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING TASK FORCE DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Riikonen [Page 54]